Make a booking
Call us: 01834 843033



Award Winning Welsh Cake Recipe

Image title


As a little girl born and bred in South Wales, March 1st meant being dressed up by my parents and sent off to school wearing a little welsh girls outfit, complete with a little black hat and a wilting daffodil pinned to my front. Welsh songs would be sung and the famous welsh cakes would be devoured. 


As an adult however, our traditions have changed slightly yet the pride the Welsh have for their country hasn’t wavered - especially amongst our primarily Welsh staff at Penally Abbey! 

Yes we may not be doing particularly well in the 6 nations right now, but one thing we are certainly talented at is making WELSH CAKES. 

After many heated debates, good natured rivalry, talks of the ‘perfect’ technique and what defined the ultimate welsh cake, we decided to officially put the claims to the test and the ‘Penally Abbey Welsh Cake Competition’ was born. 


All entries were asked to make their own batch of welsh cakes, 9 in total, to present to a board of blind tasters. The kitchen was a no talking zone and any buried competitive streak anyone had came bubbling to the surface. 

Image title


Each delicious little welsh cake was critically rated by each person on the tasting committee (which was made up of house keeping, front of house, maintenance and any passers by!!) out of five for taste, look and texture. 

Image title


It was a tough competition with a lot riding on the title of ‘BEST WELSH CAKE AT PENALLY ABBEY’ and tensions were high. Every cake was completely delicious so the board of tasters got brutal with their score cards and considered each cake carefully. 

Image title

Image title

Image title

Beating Rachael Morgan by just two points, Melanie took the title!! 

With the most experience and years making her famous welsh cakes she took the 2018 crown and her winning recipe is below…


Image title

Image title

MEL'S AWARD WINNING RECIPE adaptation of Mary Berry's recipe


12 oz self raising flour

2 teaspoons baking powder

6 oz butter

4 1/2 oz caster sugar

4 oz currants

3/4 teaspoon mixed spice

around 2 tablespoons of milk

caster sugar for sprinkling to serve


Prepare a heavy based frying pan (preferably non stick) with a little oil on the heat or ideally use the cooler top on the aga if you have one!

Measure the flour and baking powder into a large bowl and rub in the butter so it resembles fine breadcrumbs. Add sugar, currants and spice. Beat the egg with the milk and add this to the mixture and mix to form a firm dough adding a little more milk if necessary. 

Roll out the dough on a lightly powered work surface to a thickness of around 5mm and cut into rounds with a fluted round cutter. 

Cook the welsh cakes on the griddle on a low heat for about 3 minutes on each side until golden brown. Be careful not to cook them too fast, otherwise the centres will be fully cooked through. 

Cool on a wire rack and then dust with caster sugar. They are best eaten on the day of making and are delicious serve with a dollop of butter!

Have a wonderful day celebrating and have a very happy St.David's Day!!

Saskia x

Leave a comment

Fields with * are required.

Please enter the letters as they are shown in the image above.
Letters are not case-sensitive.